Jun 19, 2007

Communal living

We have all grown up in a so called 'middle class' upbringing. Joint families, jurassic age neighbors, teachers who have taught your uncles, knowing the number of wrinkles of everyone in your neighborhood..the works. And that's supposed to be Utopia.

Maybe it is. Maybe not. That's not the point. The point is, Hollywood (and then automatically Bollywood and then any wood) INSISTS that 'the golden age has gone'. The age of communal living, sharing, helping, adjusting, frustating...i dont know, i have run out of 'ing' words. But that's maybe because i have never lived in a chawl, or a 'para' or whatever vernacular a commune goes by.

AAAAH! The concept of the chawl! Where else will one find a potboiler such as a chawl, where everyone's worry is everone else's and every joy, sorrow, rage, madness is distributed and broken down in tiny little pieces, so that finally there is nothing left, apart from the numbing dreary meaningless existence where nothing really matters, where it all comes down to the lowest common denominator, who wakes up to fill the buckets, who gets the first shot at the virgin loo, who gets the first steaming loaf of bread from the yawning delivery boy. But then, at the end of day, if u havent done anything of the above, have failed to achieve each and every one of these magnificient tasks, well..the chawl is waiting. You go back, and find other people who are at your level, failures in all that they have attempted today, and cosy, comfortable and cushioned in the communal feeling..that fraternity of failed brotherhood, a brotherhood where everyone is happy, and no one dares voice their deepest, darkest insecurities, where brothers in arms perish together, happy for the warmth, succumbing to that numbing nothingness.

So..which 'chawl' are you in?

32 comments:

ghetufool said...

i love it, i loved it shuv. it's beautiful writing!

as for your question, i am too afraid to answer that. because i need brothers-in-arms in this.

arcane said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
arcane said...

I think we all want to belong to a chawl..but 'affsos'..life has become too demanding and lonely to get attached to your own shadow,leave alone a chawl...however friends and colleagues (more so of opposite gender) provide a nice feel good feeling sometimes...

Anonymous said...

dear shuv, amazing post.
like an old wine you taste better and better with every passing day.

Still.. can't help myself from asking...is it only your writing skills which go on improving with time or..has there been an overall makeover in the way you had always looked at things.

don't know why..but do i still get the smell of a cynical,'superiority'- obsessed individual who has always remained proud and depressed for the very same reason....his lonliness.

dear shuv, your idea of 'failure','success'and 'level' sucks. It only shows you still have no understanding of the requirements of a human soul...

no 'intelligent' conversation can ever replace a warm hug.

A human simply needs another human..period.(a pet simply wont do..)
and no electronic gadgets can ever make that change.

What do you mean by 'failed brotherhood'and 'deepest,darkest
insecurities' bro?? dont your 'successful'brotherhood share the same deepest insecurities?

r u jealous of the 'chawl'?.. as all the westerners have always been towards the Indians for their unexplainable , seemingly meaningless happiness?

dear shuv, without the heart...i'm afraid, you remain an extremely efficient,articulate,well informed......

bio computer.

a chawl is definitely an extreme example but you are also dwelling on the other extreme.

I'm sorry..sweetheart.

Vikas said...

Yes the golden age is over and "chawl" is a thing of past. I agree with all the woods.

kaushik said...

Rip: Welcome back. But I will give you the pass on this one. And just read.

Shuv: This post touched a chord. A chord which keeps on harping every now and then.

Today my brother will be leaving & going for his first 'Job'. And I have a feeling we will not meet frequently and over long stretched of time.

Leave alone the chawl we are all so nucleated. Me, wife, kid thing. And for some not even that and just the low frills airlines, or the overnight train of bus trips to catch up with your nucleus.

Sometimes I feel it is not worth it. But then its been always evolving and soon we will be dead.

Shuv said...

ghetu: thank u thank u thank u

arcane: welcome to the blog

rip: as usual, u have judged people whom u havent even met. if u had known me (as others on the blog do) u would have known that i dont go by the current definitions of success and failure. to me a successful person is one who goes to bed at night content with what he has done in the day. and people living in chawls are not successful, as they live with permanent regrets..but you wouldnt know that because again, u r talking about people u havent met.

vikas: 'woods'?

koushik: u r still in a chawl.

Vikas said...

hollywood, bollywood and any other wood.

kaushik said...

Well I live in a modern chawl. With all the fun of old chawl living taken out.

Yesterday we had a neighbour visiting us to say hello. But i dont think it will last bcoz she looked completely off the radar for Mun.

Anonymous said...

dear shuv, we all have prermanent regtrets.only the people in the chawl have someone to share it with.
that makes a lot of difference.In lonliness,even a small regret can drive you nuts.
Dont u feel this 'success,status,achievement' thing has raised such an artificial barrier.. a vast chasm around us that we r left completely impotent in communicating with another human being?
i think the word 'individuality' has not been defined correctly.Why otherwise is it always associated with lonliness?
dear bro would u like to be extremely independent,successful and completely neurotic...or...moderately independent,moderately successful and a reasonably sane person?

Shuv said...

moderately independent and successful..sanity is in the eye of the beholder. an insane person probably feels he is the sanest person around.

Anonymous said...

rip,
just wanted to point out that you got carried away by your metaphors and sparked the following question in my mind:

How can one RAISE a chasm?

Hmmmm....?

And btw, like the buper sticker goes - I DON'T SUFFER FROM INSANITY, I ENJOY EVERY MINUTE OF IT !!!

Anonymous said...

dear dd, how's life? hope you are doing great.nice hearing from u.

no, chasm cannot be raised...i was talking about 'raising' a barrier....

dear dd, i'm sorry, but i dont lead my life based on 'stickers'.

dear bro,there are thousands of stickers and millions of captions (specially in the western world)to throw you off line, to distract you from the real path of life.

the biggest problem with these captions are... they never assume any responsibility.
they are simply 'catchy', designed for the sole purpose of confusing people to sell some stupid and useless products.

Actually dd, you dont need to endorse this caption...the whole world is a big proof of this.

never in the history of human consciousness has man 'enjoyed'
being insane so much as he is enjoying now.

I guess Hitler, Hiroshima, George Bush would do fine as an example.
oh..how about the not so old Nithari case in our very own India!

Long live Insanity...enjoy your ride.
i would rather watch.

Anonymous said...

dear shuv,it pains me to see you still write things you simply dont believe....

... insanity which is associated with some kind of creativity brings about a certain kind of bliss within the person ( although outwardly he might look totally disoriented);
on the other hand, insanity which is associated with some kind destruction will keep tormenting and agitating the person from inside(however composed and oriented he might pose from outside)..

it really doesn't depend on the eye of the beholder..at least the consequences dont.

kaushik said...

RIP: On close read of all the post I have question "With what r you disagreeing?" Or are you just making a point?

Anonymous said...

dear kaushik, i'm disagreeing with the modern concept of 'success'...Looks like a devil's joke on the human race.

it is found that.."to be successful in the outside world is to fail deeply in the inside."

Normally, as a person goes up the ladder of success and security,he progressively goes on sacrificing his happiness,joy,relatins and emotions...as if it was an 'exchange offer' given to you by the society to remain on top...the price to be successful has always been ...lonliness & autism.

dear kaushik, i'm against this mad rush to be 'successful' and find out (at 60 yrs)that we have been cheated by the society...

that you have excanged your diamond for a handful of stones!

the proof of this you will see in the face of every successful old man's ...because he knows that he has been cheated of his happiness,his dreams,his youth, his love..his whole life.. only to fulfill some stupid social norms....simply because everyone else is doing it! and there is no more time left...he had only one chance, and he wasted it in bying things he did not want..to impress people he did not like.

i'm not against money.
i'm simply against the obsession and destruction which goes behind acquiring it, preserving it and admiring it.

ghetufool said...

this rip van is bloody damn humorous.

and bloody argumentative.

Shuv said...

thats why he wasnt there at the blogger's meet ghetu..he would have got a 'bloody' nose.

Anonymous said...

Well, let me just say that I was just raising a point of grammar, but WWELLLLL! Just give me some of that dope that RIP is smoking. I think there's hope for India yet! With so much passion abounding ...

If I may lighten up the mood some ... some of you may have heard it ... and ladies, I apologize

THERE ONCE WAS A MAN FROM MADRAS
WHOSE BALLS WERE MADE OUT OF BRASS
ON DAYS OF STORMY WEATHER
THOSE THINGS WOULD CLANG TOGETHER
AND LIGHTNING WOULD COME OUT OF HIS ARSE

Thank you and to all ... a good night

Vikas said...

i like what RIP has written, a dose of believer's thoughts . Well done mate. STOP PICKING ON HIM.

kaushik said...

Vikas: I dont see anybody picking anyone here.

RIP: I understand your dillemma now. You would want to propound a point of view. But you dont have the patience to run a blog of your own. Or may be you have one and wont want to keep it secret.

So what you do is to pick on somebody's post and just like "gorur essay" start an argument.

My view about you. You are as erudite and well versed as most that I have seen in this blog world. I think everybody will give into that. No questions on that.

So I suggest you start writing on your blog and we will visit it with due diligence and then get to know more about your ways of the world.

On your success part of the comment. I agree with you and I disagree. But i cant move on this anymore. Shuv is going to throw me out now.

kaushik said...

RIP: I just forgot to mention. You are so like me. Except that your "gorur essay" thing always keeps you on the other side of the fence.

Anonymous said...

koushik, i loved the 'gorur essay' bit.

kaushik said...

MuniaD! I think I have heard this name so many a times. But we have never met. Thanks for the compliment.

Shuv said...

my god munia! u r alive!

Anonymous said...

dear bloggers, are u suggesting that to comment on a blog one needs to have his own blog???

how will that change the comments?

hi Munia!!! welcome back !i've heard..
'heaven hath no rage like love to harted turned; nor hell a fury like a woman scorned'....

still scorned? tch...tch..

Anonymous said...

dear kaushik, i'm sorry ,but i've totally missed the 'gorur essay' thing.

dear ghetu, how old are u? 27?

Anonymous said...

abar shuru holo......ami abar out. scorned??!!!! duh!!!

Anonymous said...

dear munia, sorry friend..

..but what can i say? you seem to be totally against me from the very beginning...by default.

Anonymous said...

dear munia, sorry friend..

..but what can i say? you seem to be totally against me from the very beginning...by default.

Shuv said...

ufff

Shuv said...

there goes shukhen again